[meteorite-list] View points

From: Ingo Herkstroeter <metopaster_at_meteoritecentral.com>
Date: Sat, 17 Mar 2007 00:06:21 +0100
Message-ID: <002e01c7681f$b6760050$0873a8c0_at_Geobase>

Hi Martin, Mike and List!

First of all the e-mail to Armando was a private one and shouldn't go to
the list! I don't know why Armando posted it (mistake, I think) and it's
also not very important for me! I stand to that, I have written in the
mail. But I have seen Martin, that you never have understand, what my
point was and still is really.

The goal of this list is (in my understanding) to let knowledge about
meteorites and related things growth. It's not the place for personal
fights or blaming. I hate, for example, the game between Mike and Matteo
and also the lot of mails, which follow them, where others say, that
they hate it. Same was the game with Steve a while ago. For me such
fights in a public forum are childish, nothing more. So if I had to say
something to this subject: I posted it directly to these persons, but
not to the list. This sort of post, was it, that I send to Armando to
say him, that I think in a way like he, but that a personal attack is
not the way.

Martin, you have attacked my view of meteorites and meteorite business
directly, but you show very clearly for me, that you have absolutely
missed my point:
I don't have problems with the cutting of a meteorite generally. How one
should make research without cutting? How to discover strange inclusions
or uncommon minerals in them, without cutting? Simply not possible!
I also don't have problems with the fact, that you and others (and yes,
me too) make money with them, while one cut them.

I have two view points on meteorites you have mixed up:

1. Personally collection view point:

I like individuals and full slices more than fragments and part slices.
I like slices with crust more than these without and I like fresh
material more than weathered. Bigger is also better!
You maybe have realized that viewpoint as you offered me an individual
for my resell last year, which I didn't wanted, cause I had to cut it
there for.
I don't like meteorite spheres, carvings and so on.

2. Generally (or lets say more scientific) viewpoint

Meteorites are rocks, so they not only have a typical mineral
composition, for each class, they have a typical structure, also!! If
you have two rocks with the same mineral composition, but different
structures, you have two different rocks.
My problems with some dealers start exactly on that point: If they begin
to cut meteorites under that size, and that only for a little bit more
money. As a small example lets take a lunar meteorite (lunar material is
still the material, which becomes cut in very small slices, micros or
what ever, caused by a very high price per gram and a big publicity, so
one can make good money):
Let's take DAG 400 as a classic lunar sample: DAG 400 is classified as
anorthositic breccia, containing granulitic fragments, intergranularly
recrystallized anorthosites and mineral fragments. How can a micro slice
represent all these components? It can't! Sometimes it can be hard to
cut a slice under 1 gram, which even shows completely matrix surrounded
anorthositic clasts. So in smaller slices (mm size or micros) all the
expressiveness (in a petrologic way) is lost. This is not the interest
of science and it should surely not be the interest of a collector also.
The second thing here is the cut lose, for smaller slices much more
higher, so more of the material is lost for ever
In this way I don't like (most of) the Chladni Cases (especially not the
"S" sized ones)!
We all know that it can happen, that a slice breaks and you get micros,
but a special production of these is a different thing.

Martin, you see it's not the "IF" you make money with meteorites, is
more the "HOW" you make it.

That's my opinion, nothing more and nothing less! Not better than yours,
but surely not lesser worth than yours also!

By the way, Martin! I don't know, what you mean with this:
"And I saw you in past of course selling small slices and cuts, also
from
your Moroccan exotic stones too, which you cut down."

The only material from meteorites, which I have classified and sold by
Ebay were OCs not very exotic! ;) The exotic stuff and also all main
masses (OC or not) will remain in my collection!

Hope we will have a good discussion one day, while sitting somewhere
with a beer or wine!!!

Best Wishes

Ingo

 

 



-----Urspr?ngliche Nachricht-----
Von: meteorite-list-bounces at meteoritecentral.com
[mailto:meteorite-list-bounces at meteoritecentral.com] Im Auftrag von
Martin Altmann
Gesendet: Freitag, 16. M?rz 2007 13:30
An: 'Armando Afonso'; meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
Betreff: Re: [meteorite-list] Fw: all List members & MikereThreatsfromMr
Gregory

Hi Armando,

but with your view we would have to throw Founder Chladni, Schreibers
(father of modern meteoritics), Brezina, Daubree, Maskelyne,
Reichenbach,
Ward, Fletcher, Cohen, Nininger et al. out of the pantheon of
meteoritics,
cause they were all such immoral looters or bought from such unethical
predators, you're complaining about.
Not a single one of the top 20 institutional collections of the world,
wasn't built up with meteorites, acquired in that way, which you condemn
to
be highly unethical!

(Huh, I almost was tempted to ride the horse, what for immense treasures
are
assembled in the large museums of Portugal due to its colonial history).

And Armando, how do you think that today science or art museums,
universities, institutions are getting their stuff? They are simply
buying
it! Aside from a few donations (and be sure, that several meteorite
dealers
do donate too).

Why should it be different with meteorites? The past showed, that those
institutions weren't comparably successful in hunting meteorites as
private
expeditions were or that if they were successful the monetary expenses
were
much higher, than if they would have simply bought the stones either
from
the hunters, which are working on their own financial risk and expenses
or
in Morocco.
The find quotas, the delivery of free material mandatory, if one wants
to
get a stone recognised, the expenses Antarctica or Space Flight versus
buying prices, I don't have to itinerate here, as we had it a hundred
times
on the list here.

And take the initial reason, why you are so furious about commercial
dealers, which obviously was the circumstance, that Farmer bought
Ourique.
He's sitting on another continent, the seller was a private person, so
why
the heck couldn't have bought any Portuguese institution the stone from
the
finder? Why Farmer was able to recover months after the fall still
fragments, which were scattered in wind&weather since Xmas around the
pit in
the dirt road??
Do you think, it would be of concern to the owner of the stones, to whom
he
sells his stone? You could have travelled also there to "rescue" the
stones
for science.

What do you think would be the best solution? National laws, which
declare
all meteorites being property of the respective state?
Would that be fair to those laypeople, who discover the stones of new
falls,
would that be ethical against the land owners on whose properties old
and
new finds were made?
Who would then go on the hunt? Nobody anymore and you simply could
forget
continuing the situation that hundreds and thousands of new and
sometimes
scientifically important meteorites would be retrieved.
And why the heck, do you think, that j u s t the meteorite dealers and
hunters should be so moral, to enforce laws to prohibit their work?
Is it their job?

And if you personally feel such ethical obligations, what keeps you away
>from raising funds to acquire meteorites to donate them to
institutions, to
"rescue" them for science. There are big collectors, who buy from time
to
time nice specimens to donate them to museums ect.
So get started, Armando!

And Ingo please:

> I think like you in a way! Many dealers, who are part of this list, do
> look at meteorites only in a profit oriented way. They are not really
> interested in the material and its scientific importance. The list is
> only a big publicity place for them, nothing more.

Stop it, we can't hear it anymore!!!
My experience with those apostles blaming the dealers to destroy their
stones driven by greed is, that whenever you offer to exactly those
accusants an entire stone or a substantial specimen,
they will answer: Who, me? Why me? Oh no no, I'm much to poor...the
others
should... and so on. - or, if they have the budget to buy large pieces,
they
ward off such more moral offers in suggesting prices below the costs of
the
dealers and far below the costs, they would have to pay by themselves,
if
they would have organized the material (but in most cases they wouldn't
have
been able to do so at all).

Do you think the dealers wouldn't like to spare time and work in selling
their treasures as complete stones? It would by so comfortable for them!
And honestly, you personally are no exception to that rule.
(And I saw you in past of course selling small slices and cuts, also
from
your Moroccan exotic stones too, which you cut down).

And not to forget Ingo & Armando, if there wouldn't exist those persons,
who
you are trying to criminalize,
NOT a single piece of meteorite would be in your collections.

Buckleboo.
Martin

PS: Armando, how are the results with the experiment with your butcher,
baker...?




> Hi Ingo,
> You are right, the message was perhaps too strong.
> I probably would take one or two words from it, now.
> Patience.
> But I still remember the insults that I received when the discussion
was
> with me.
> Many of this so-called "meteorite hunters" are not far from criminals
(at
> least from a moral perspective), simply taking advantage of the
absence of
> specific legislation in most of the countries, and people`s naivety.

> Call
> it enterpreneurs attitude, if you prefer.
> Some of them were selling hamburguers, or plumbing, before entering
into
> their new "scientific" activity...
> I am sorry if I do not simpatize with them.
> I must add that obviously SOME of them too are great people, with an
> honest
> interest and real knowledge on the subject.
> Those would have much more to say in list than the usual "stars".
> Regards.
> AA
>
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Ingo Herkstroeter" <metopaster at gmx.de>
> To: "'Armando Afonso'" <armandoafonso at oniduo.pt>
> Sent: Tuesday, March 13, 2007 1:46 PM
> Subject: AW: [meteorite-list] all List members & Mike re ThreatsfromMr

> Gregory
>
>
> Hi Armando!
>
> I think like you in a way! Many dealers, who are part of this list, do
> look at meteorites only in a profit oriented way. They are not really
> interested in the material and its scientific importance. The list is
> only a big publicity place for them, nothing more.
> The cut the material into crumbs and tell they would serve the science
> and so on..... They see the list as a place for personal fights and
not
> as a place to let knowledge growth!
>
> I'm pissed of this behaviour and I know a lot of list members (like
you
> and many more) too!
>
> Armando, please don't go down to their level and attack someone
> personally, like you have done in the mail below. This should not be
our
> way!
>
> Try to make your protest in a smarter way....
>
> Best Wishes!
>
> Ingo
>
> -----Urspr?ngliche Nachricht-----
> Von: meteorite-list-bounces at meteoritecentral.com
> [mailto:meteorite-list-bounces at meteoritecentral.com] Im Auftrag von
> Armando Afonso
> Gesendet: Samstag, 10. M?rz 2007 23:12
> An: Michael L Blood; Michael Farmer; Meteorite List
> Betreff: Re: [meteorite-list] all List members & Mike re ThreatsfromMr
> Gregory
>
> Dear friends,
>>>>From time to time, I take the time and patience to read what is
> happening in
> this list.
> Invariably, Mike Farmer is exchanging insults with someone...
> If this list was something near neutrality, this gentleman would have
> been
> banned long, long ago...
> Anyway, from a certain distance, this fights can be very amusing, too.
> Pitty that the only interest of the meteorites for this guys is the
> potential profit, nothing else.
> Apart from his predator attitude, arrogance, irritability and
scientific
>
> ignorance, what are his atributes?
> AA
>
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Michael L Blood" <mlblood at cox.net>
> To: "Michael Farmer" <meteoriteguy at yahoo.com>; "Meteorite List"
> <meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com>
> Sent: Saturday, March 10, 2007 8:19 PM
> Subject: Re: [meteorite-list] all List members & Mike re Threats
fromMr
> Gregory
>
>
>> on 3/10/07 8:11 AM, Michael Farmer at meteoriteguy at yahoo.com wrote:
>>> List members, this man is now making threats to my
>>> home and family...... Read this and tell me..........
>> --
>> Dear Mike and all,
>> Mike, would it help if you KNEW that NO ONE on the list wanted
>> to read ANY of the posts about issues you and this fellow have with
>> one another? If you knew that would you then spare us hearing about
> it???
>> I experience you as a fairly intelligent fellow, so, please,
> PLEASE
>> pay attention:
>> --------------
>> I suggest EVERYONE on the list think very carefully and decide
>> if they want to hear about this dispute between Mike and this fellow.
>> If even ONE list member WANTS to hear about it, please post to the
>> list your opinion to this effect.
>> -------------
>> Mike - if NO ONE responds, perhaps you could leave your
> emotions
>> in check for just a moment, fall back on your ample intelligence and
> keep
>> any communications with this fellow strictly between you and him, as
>> clearly, out of the hundreds of list members you will have heard for
>> yourself that NOT ONE of the list members wants to hear about it.
>> Sincerely, Michael
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> ______________________________________________
>> Meteorite-list mailing list
>> Meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
>> http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
>>
>
>
> ______________________________________________
> Meteorite-list mailing list
> Meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
> http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
>
>


______________________________________________
Meteorite-list mailing list
Meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list

______________________________________________
Meteorite-list mailing list
Meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
Received on Fri 16 Mar 2007 07:06:21 PM PDT